Shipshewana Hotels Guide: The Best Hotels for Family Fun

Our Adventure Is Everywhere contains affiliate links and is a member of the Amazon Services LLC Affiliate Program. If you make a purchase using one of my Amazon or other affiliate links, I may receive compensation at no additional cost to you. Read my full privacy policy for more information.

Shipshewana is a hidden gem tucked away in Indiana’s Amish country. This quaint town, with its rolling farmlands and friendly locals, offers a refreshing escape from the hustle and bustle of daily life. It’s a place where families can step back in time, slow down, and create lasting memories together. Especially if they select one of these perfect Shipshewana hotels as their home base.

Whether you’re browsing the famous Shipshewana Flea Market, taking a leisurely buggy ride, or simply soaking in the serene rural landscape, Shipshewana provides a unique blend of adventure and relaxation that’s perfect for families looking to explore the Midwest. It’s one of the places I visit when I want to really “get away” from it all.

The charm of Shipshewana lies not just in its scenic beauty and Amish culture, but also in its array of attractions that cater to all ages. From exploring the Menno-Hof museum to indulging in homemade Amish treats, there’s always something to do and discover. And, after a day full of exploration and fun, finding the right place to rest and recharge is crucial.

I’ve personally visited and stayed at several hotels in and around Shipshewana, each offering its own unique flavor of hospitality and comfort, perfectly suited for families. Whether you’re looking for a hotel that puts you close to downtown Shipshewana or one that offers a more upscale atmosphere, there is a hotel for you. Here is my curated list of the best family-friendly hotels in the area based on my experience.

A special thanks to both the Shipshewana & LaGrange Visitors Center and the Elkhart Visitors Center for hosting me on various occasions. The opinions in this post are 100% mine.

Amish horse and buggy driving down a street in Shipshewana Indiana

Places to Stay In Shipshewana Indiana

If you want a hotel located in the town of Shipshewana there are several choices I’d recommend. From the rustic allure of The Farmstead Inn to the cozy, tradition-rich environment of The Blue Gate Garden Inn, and the centrally located comfort of The Van Buren Hotel, any of these three hotels would be wonderful picks for your family trip.

Farmstead Inn lobby decorated for Christmas.

1. The Farmstead Inn: a taste of country living

The Farmstead Inn & Conference Center is located next to the famous Shipshewana Flea Market, so if you are planning on a visit there, it’s a wonderful choice. This large Inn has several gorgeous gathering areas, a free buffet breakfast, an indoor ping-pong room as well as an indoor basketball court, an indoor pool and hot tub, and plenty of spacious and comfortable rooms.

On my last visit to Shipshewana, I spent three lovely nights at the Farmstead Inn and it was perfect for my needs. I especially appreciated the free coffee in the lobby and the large room. Everything was super clean too, so no worries there. When I stayed it was November, so the over-the-top gorgeous Christmas decorations around the Inn really made for a special stay.

Rooms are quite affordable and include a microwave and mini-fridge for leftovers or quick snacks. Note that there isn’t a restaurant on-site, so you’ll have to head elsewhere for lunch/dinner.

Check rates and room types for your family-friendly stay at The Farmstead Inn HERE!

Blue Gate Garden Inn in Shipshewana Indiana sign

2. The Blue Gate Garden Inn: where hospitality meets tradition

If you are at all familiar with Shipshewana, odds are good you have heard of the Blue Gate. Not only is there a Blue Gate Garden Inn (highly recommended), but also a Blue Gate Restaurant & Theatre in town, and the Blue Gate Performing Arts Center.

The Performing Arts Center (PAC) is located right next door to the Blue Gate Garden Inn, so this hotel would be my top pick if I was seeing a concert there – talk about convenience!

The Blue Gate Garden Inn is cozy and comfortable and a lovely place to make your home base when you visit Shipshewana. It’s very family-friendly, with spacious and comfortable rooms, a free morning breakfast, and so much more. There is an indoor pool, pickleball court, basketball court, and firepit area – all perfect for family fun.

Look for the best rates for your Shipshewana trip to the Blue Gate Garden Inn HERE.

Shipshewana mural

3. The Van Buren Hotel: comfort in the heart of Shipshewana

My final suggestion for a hotel stay in Shipshewana is the Van Buren Hotel. This hotel has comfortable guest rooms with a mini-fridge and microwave, 24/7 coffee/tea/hot chocolate, and a free breakfast.

Some of the hotel’s amenities include an indoor pool, a small fitness center, and board game rental. I love the board game rental – we take advantage of this often when we visit Vero Beach in Florida, and it’s a fun way to spend an evening at a hotel with the kids. Make some hot chocolate, find a cozy corner, and have some quality family time!

Check out rates for the Van Buren Hotel in Shipshewana HERE

Lobby at Essenhaus Inn in Middlebury Indiana

Hotels near Shipshewana IN

If none of these hotels fit your needs, there are several others I’d recommend that are nearby. Both of these options are quite different, but excellent choices depending upon your preferences and needs.

4. The Essenhaus in nearby Middlebury

The Essenhaus Inn is part of a lovely complex in nearby Middlebury, Indiana. In addition to beautiful rooms (each one a little bit different), the Inn has cozy spots to hang out and a delicious restaurant (Das Essenhaus) on site. Plus, right across the street is a whole little village full of unique shops well worth exploring as well as a miniature golf course.

Pam’s insider tip: Don’t miss Das Essenhaus if you are staying at the Essenhaus Inn – it is comfort food at its finest!

There are two sections to the Inn, the newer part and the older area (called the Atrium). The newer section is set up more like standard hotel rooms while the older section has a variety of unique rooms. Regardless of which section you stay in, you’ll be quite comfortable.

The Essenhaus Inn has an indoor pool, fitness room, and paved trails, perfect for short walks in the morning. Some of the rooms even have balconies – which is a huge bonus in my book – there is nothing I love more than enjoying my morning coffee with a good book on a balcony when we are traveling.

Book your stay at The Essenhaus HERE!

Hotel Elkhart room

5. The Hotel Elkhart: blending history with modern comfort

If you prefer a stay that is a bit bougie, then you’ll enjoy The Hotel Elkhart. Although a little further from Shipshewana, it’s within easy driving distance and in a lovely location in downtown Elkhart. The hotel is beautifully decorated with comfortable, spacious rooms and has a fantastic coffee shop in the lobby for grabbing a strong, hand-crafted drink before you start your day.

The hotel also boasts a wonderful restaurant with a variety of tasty dishes and fun cocktails. If the weather is nice it’s a lovely place to sit out on the patio and have dinner and drinks. Overall, if you prefer a more traditional hotel stay, the Hotel Elkhart should be your pick. I loved staying at this hotel and am actively looking for a free weekend to get back up to Elkhart and stay there again!

Note: there is no pool at this hotel, so if you are traveling with kids who think pools are the best part of a hotel experience, this wouldn’t be the right choice.

Another thing to consider when visiting Shipshewana is that almost everything is closed on Sunday, but there are still many things to do in Elkhart. So, for a long weekend, maybe book two nights in Shipshewana and then Saturday night at Hotel Elkhart – just a suggestion!

Book your stay at the Hotel Elkhart!

Outside of Hotel Elkhart

Map of Hotels in Shipshewana Indiana

FAQs: Shipshewana Hotels

Is Shipshewana worth a visit?

Yes! Between the excellent shopping, delicious food, and wonderful atmosphere, Shipshewana is a fantastic weekend getaway in Indiana.

Can you drink at a Shipshewana hotel?

No, alcohol is not served or allowed at the hotels listed in Shipshewana. The Hotel Elkhart has a bar, so if you’d like a drink in the evening, this would be your best hotel bet.

Do you need a car to visit Shipshewana?

Yes, you really do need a car to get the most out of your visit to Shipshewana.

Farmstead Inn & Conference Center in Shipshewana Indiana

Conclusion: Where to Stay in Shipshewana Indiana

As I wrap up our journey through Shipshewana’s delightful hotel options, I can’t help but reflect on my own experiences staying at several of these charming places. Each hotel brought its unique flavor to my adventures, blending comfort with the inviting spirit of the region.

Whether it was the rustic charm of The Farmstead Inn, the warm hospitality of The Blue Gate Inn, or the bougie feel of the Hotel Elkhart, each stay contributed to my treasure trove of weekend getaway memories.

Shipshewana, with its serene landscapes and rich cultural traditions, is a destination well worth visiting. The hotels in and around this quaint town are more than just places to sleep—they’re gateways to exploring and enjoying what this unique area has to offer.

Whether you’re here for the bustling flea market, the peaceful countryside, or the simple joy of disconnecting from the everyday rush, you’re sure to find a hotel that fits your family’s needs and enhances your Shipshewana experience. So, pack your bags and get ready to create some unforgettable family moments in this charming corner of Indiana.

Planning your trip to Shipshewana? Don’t miss these posts for everything you need for a perfect getaway:


Planning a memorable family vacation? Look no further! Our blog post showcases the best hotels in and around Shipshewana, so you can focus on creating unforgettable experiences with your loved ones. From fun-filled days exploring the Amish countryside to relaxing nights in comfortable accommodations, these hotels have it all. Book your stay now and let the adventure begin!
Planning a memorable family vacation? Look no further! Our blog post showcases the best hotels in and around Shipshewana, so you can focus on creating unforgettable experiences with your loved ones. From fun-filled days exploring the Amish countryside to relaxing nights in comfortable accommodations, these hotels have it all. Book your stay now and let the adventure begin!