sugar creek winery

Sugar Creek Winery

From the inviting firepit to the welcoming servers, Sugar Creek Winery delivers a perfect weeknight escape.

As soon as you walk up to the entrance, you know this is going to be a lovely evening. The firepit outside (on a nice large patio) gives off enough heat that I think you could enjoy a glass of wine out there even in the winter – which is unheard of for January in Indiana. Regardless of the temperature, it was one of many well-thought-out touches you’ll discover throughout the winery.

Sugar Creek Winery in Carmel, Indiana

Inside, the atmosphere is cozy, warm, and comfortable. With a rustic, outdoorsy feel, the decor lends itself to a night of relaxation. Sugar Creek’s large wine bar was created from reclaimed wood – and there is a large picture above the bar of the barn the wood was sourced from. Love that! In addition to the wine bar, there are a few comfortable round tables (better for conversation per the owner, David) as well as a separate room that can be reserved for small group events.

Barn used for wine tasting bar wood at Sugar Creek Winery in Carmel, IndianaDuring our visit, David the owner shared with us a little bit about the history of Sugar Creek Winery as well as the vineyards. His passion for both good wine and outdoor adventure (especially white water rafting) was infectious.

Sugar Creek Winery has an interesting variety of both dry and sweet wines. Although David has been growing grapes in Montgomery County, Indiana since 2012, the tasting room has only been open for six months. The vineyard is 2.5 acres and grows enough grapes for about 10,000 bottles each year. What David can’t grow in Indiana, he imports from Chile, California or wherever he feels he can get the best quality grapes for his wines.

The Sugar Creek tasting room is really starting to find its groove with regular events such as ladies’ night (ladies get 2 for 1 wine tastings starting at 6 PM) on Tuesdays and Open Mic night at 7:00 on the 2nd and 4th Wednesday each month. David also mentioned a variety of special events such as a cheese and wine pairings night with local company Tulip Tree Creamery and various classes such as painting and flower arranging. Fun stuff!

Sugar Creek Winery in Carmel, Indiana

Something I love that is a bit unique about this tasting room is that pets are allowed – inside! Kids are also welcome, and I know we are always on the lookout for places that allow us to bring the whole family. Aside from some locally sourced meat and cheese plates, food isn’t served, but it can be purchased from nearby restaurants or patrons are welcome to bring in whatever food they’d like.

After touring Sugar Creek Winery and spending time with David, we felt a wine tasting was in order. Our server, Adam, was engaging and knowledgable. He led us through the tasting with a lot of one-on-one attention and fun conversation. Once we shared the types of wines we tended to enjoy, he was able to guide us towards the Sugar Creek wines he felt we’d like the most. He certainly knew what he was doing as we each found a wine we absolutely loved. It was the 2016 Crystal Rapid Sauvignon Blanc for me and the 2016 Terminator Rapid Malbec for my husband. A bottle may or may not have come home with us for later!

Our visit to Sugar Creek Winery was a lovely way to spend a cold Tuesday night and we will definitely return soon. A perfect everyday adventure right in my own back yard.

Love visiting local wineries? Check out these other Hamilton County Wineries!

The details:

Sugar Creek Vineyards & Winery, 1111 West Main Street, Suite 165, Carmel, IN

Hours are 3 PM – 9 PM Tuesday – Thursday, Friday 3 PM -10 PM, Saturday 1 PM – 10 PM, Sunday 1 PM -8 PM

Do you enjoy visiting wineries? What is your favorite part?

Pin for later: Sugar Creek winery

Similar Posts


  1. My favorite part of visiting a winery is sitting outside with the grapes surrounding us and drinking a good glass of wine. We tend to like sweet wine, so a moscato, reisling or pinot grigio.

  2. We have several wineries here in NE Ohio. One of my favorites was made from two old barns that were taken down and repurposed. It’s a great addition to our community, just as the Sugar Creek Winery appears to be.

  3. sounds like a great place to visit, so cozy and inviting. Love that pets and kids alike are invited. It is always a treat to find people that are so invested in their craft.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *